Monday, January 21, 2019

Legal Geek No. 158: Netflix sued by owners of Choose Your Own Adventure

Welcome back to Legal Geek. This week, we won't be rapping like last week, but instead, choosing our own adventure, as we cover how the owners of that brand of books sued Netflix last week for potential trademark infringement and dilution.

LINK

As you probably know, Netflix received critical acclaim and positive fan reaction to continuing the British anthology science fiction dystopian series Black Mirror. In the most recent iteration, Netflix made a Black Mirror movie entitled Bandersnatch, in which a computer programmer is making a video game version of a Choose Your Own Adventure book.  Like the books, viewers have the chance to direct which of many branching paths the story goes down using their remote.

Although this has also been done in some other streaming TV works like children's shows, the direct mention of a "Choose" book and its central place in the story set in 1984 for this movie was too much according to the brand owner of this book series.  That company is Chooseco, a company formed in the mid-2000s by one of the original creators of the series.  Chooseco has relaunched the Choose Your Own Adventure book series, selling approximately 15 million books since that time.

One legal theory that Chooseco sues Netflix on is trademark infringement, namely in the use of the Choose name in the story.  Chooseco argues that this was an unauthorized use of the Choose brand that capitalized monetarily on viewers' nostalgia for those books.  Another legal theory posited is trademark dilution.  To this end, Chooseco argues that the dark and sometimes disturbing content of Bandersnatch dilutes the goodwill for and positive associations with the Choose Your Own Adventure mark, thereby tarnishing the products in the marketplace.

Unfortunately for Chooseco, filmmakers like Netflix are often protected from such claims under First Amendment or Fair Use defenses.  Netflix is not actively misleading consumers by referencing the Choose books, and it serves value in explaining how the story works to the viewer.  Furthermore, relative to dilution, the Bandersnatch film may actually improve the market and demand for Chooseco's books.  It is unlikely that a company like Netflix will be held liable under such legal theories, but every judge views a set of facts differently, so we will see how this plays out in court.

That's of course if it make sit to court at all.  Despite Netflix being in a strong legal position, it may be a legal and PR win to settle this claim and take a license from Chooseco, cutting the bookmaker into a small amount of profits from this streaming film.  That's really what Chooseco is after, a slice of the pie, and it also won't be surprising if that's what happens.

The Bottom Line is, authors of creative works like films have a lot of leeway in using known items in the world to tell their stories, and trademarks do not generally stand in the way of such creative expression.  This is only in court because of the money involved, but it does pose an interesting question.  If you'd like to see Netflix win a motion to dismiss, turn to page 47.  If you'd instead like to see Chooseco win a jury trial, turn to page 83.

----------------------------------
Do you have a question? Send it in!

Thanks for reading. Please provide feedback and legal-themed questions as segment suggestions to me on Twitter @BuckeyeFitzy


Monday, January 14, 2019

Legal Geek No. 157: The Carlton Dance lawsuit against Video Game Makers

Now this is a story all about how, 
Copyright law got turned all upside down, 
And I'd like to take a minute
Just sit right there
I'll tell you how Carlton Dance is in a court near Bel-Air

Welcome back to Legal Geek. This week, as you might have guessed, we cover the lawsuit filed last month over the use of the Carlton Dance made famous in the 90s TV show The Prince of Bel-Air in two highly popular video game franchises.

Alfonso Ribeiro is the actor who brought the character of Carlton Banks to life, in The Prince of Bel-Air. One memorable moment from that show was when Carlton dances a jig to a Tom Jones tune, and the way he flaps his arms about became forever known as "the Carlton dance." Homage to this moment has been paid in many other television shows and other contexts, but Ribeiro now says the use of such a dance in two popular video games has crossed the line of copyright infringement.

His claims are against Epic Games, who makes Fortnite, and against Take-Two Interactive, who makes the NBA 2K series. In the case of Fortnite, a purchasable emote called Fresh allows characters to dance in the style of The Carlton Dance. Both of these video game franchises have one thing in common: they make boatloads of money. Hence the primary reason this lawsuit was filed, as Ribeiro seeks a cut of that pie based on the video game developers' decision to use The Carlton Dance as a fun side element of their games.

We discussed a few segments ago the types of rights Jet Li could have been protecting in his ninja moves when he declined to do a bunch of motion capture for the Matrix filmmakers two decades ago. Any copyright Ribeiro has in this dance is based on a similar theory of artistic performance and expression, although unlike many ninja moves, this dance does have uniqueness in the field of dancing. 

Ribeiro is not the only celebrity suing these game makers under this type of legal theory, as other lawsuits by Backpack Kid, inventor of The Floss dance, and by the rapper 2 Milly are also pending in California courts.  Plus, other celebrities like Mike Tyson have sued when iconic elements of their persona or appearance were used without compensation being paid by video game or movie makers.  But does the Carlton Dance lawsuit stand a chance?

There are a few potential hurdles to overcome for this lawsuit. First, Ribeiro performed the dance while working as a performer on a TV show, so there is an argument that any copyright in the dance could be a Work Made For Hire that belongs to the show's producers instead of him. The copyright may not be valid based on U.S. copyright Office guidance offered last year saying that it cannot register short dance routines consisting of only a few movements, even if novel or distinctive. While the Carlton Dance makes for a stronger case for copyright infringement than the other current suits, there are still a lot of potential fatal flaws in this legal case to expect Ribeiro to succeed on the merits.

The Bottom Line is, once again, where there's a lot of money being made, more attention and lawsuits will follow to try and share in the wealth. There's no doubt these video game developers and others who have incorporated these dance moves before them should have attributed credit and possibly paid a small license fee to include these add-ons, especially when they are paid add-ons like in Fortnite. But the moral right thing to do is not always what is legally required, and while The Carlton Dance makes a better case than most, I suspect the court will tell Ribeiro "yo homes smell ya later" at the end of the process.

----------------------------------
Do you have a question? Send it in!

Thanks for reading. Please provide feedback and legal-themed questions as segment suggestions to me on Twitter @BuckeyeFitzy

Tuesday, December 18, 2018

Legal Geek No. 156: 2018 Wrap-up and Board Game Gifting Guide

Happy Holidays, and welcome back to Legal Geek. This week, we close out 2018 with answers to where you can find the Legal Geek content, including on other podcasts this year, and then discuss another holiday gift guide in a field we cover frequently.


Throughout the year, I receive several questions on whether there's a separate podcast for Legal Geek or another source for prior segments, especially now that this segment has reached a fifth anniversary from its start in December 2013.  While there is no separate podcast as of yet, you can always find the more than 150 prior installments of this segment over at Archive.org, under the user BuckeyeFitzy.  I also keep a running list of my scripts at legalgeekfitz.blogspot.com, but fair warning, these are typically unedited versions of the audio you find on Archive.

I also make appearances at trade shows in the tabletop and video game industry, providing educational seminars to game designers and publishers regarding my chosen field of practice, intellectual property law.  I provided seminars at Origins Game Fair in Columbus, OH and at GenCon in Indianapolis in 2018 and plan to attend both again in 2019.  There are over 300 gaming conventions in the U.S. annually, so if you know one that needs such a speaker, let me know and I'm happy to explore new ones as we move forward.

Finally, a 2018 Legal Geek recap would be incomplete without mentioning a couple of find podcasts that brought me on to guest for full shows.  As usual, I appeared on The Geek All Stars with Dan the board game man this year, specifically in Episode 166 entitled SDJ, Charterstone, and The Law Star Rides Again.  I also appeared on Ritual Misery Podcast near the beginning of the year in episode 150.  If you want a little longer form Legal Geek, check those shows out.

Before wrapping 2018, I also wanted to provide a second gift giving guide I enjoyed for this holiday season, following up on the privacy law-themed one from 2 weeks ago.  This one is just a great overall guide to the best tabletop board games, an article entitled Ars Technica's Ultimate Board Game Buyer's Guide.  If you're looking for a last minute gift and can get yourself to a local game store or Amazon prime, these lists will provide good ideas for gamers of all experience levels.

2018 was a notable year on multiple fronts, including a contentious Supreme Court replacement and multiple landmark cases at that court, including one opening the door for sports betting in all 50 states and another striking a blow at partisan gerrymandering of congressional districts.  We also had plenty of fun legal stories to cover, including the romance novelist who trademarked Cocky, and the surprising legal problems raised by the electric scooter invasion into many major cities.  

The Bottom Line is, the legal and nerd worlds keep generating interesting content and lessons to learn, and I will continue to provide insights into these fields in 2019.  Thank you for listening to this segment and supporting it with your suggestions, and also to Scott and Tom for making this a part of Current Geek for the last 5 years.

----------------------------------
Do you have a question? Send it in!

Thanks for reading. Please provide feedback and legal-themed questions as segment suggestions to me on Twitter @BuckeyeFitzy

Tuesday, December 11, 2018

Legal Geek No. 155: Web Scraping Case highlights lesser-known IP Enforcement Rights

Hi, and welcome back to Legal Geek. This week, we cover a case in Illinois from November suggested by subreddit user Gavreh that shows how internet technologies can sometimes force the spotlight on lesser known laws and methods of trying to enforce intellectual property.

The case is titled Alan Ross Machinery v. Machinio Corp., and the allegedly infringing conduct of Machinio included using web scraping to extract sales listings from Alan Ross's website and then copied those sales listings on their own site.  The copied material into the Machinio website was mostly factual and did not include specific branding of Alan Ross, so traditional enforcement of a copyright or a trademark was not really available in this case.  However, Alan Ross generated a couple of lesser-known claims under the copyright and trademark laws to try and defend their rights against this practice of web scraping.

The first claim was for violation of the Copyright Act's prohibition against distributing false copyright management information, or removing or altering such CMI.  CMI is generally defined as identifying information placed on a notice of copyright or on a work, and is most often seen online as visible watermarks on images or copyright information in metadata.  This provision came into effect as a part of the DMCA in the late 90s.  If a defendant knowingly removes or alters such CMI when distributing the underlying work, so as to disguise the potential copyright infringement, the defendant can be liable for thousands of dollars of damages under this legal claim, which is separate and independent from a traditional copyright infringement claim.  Furthermore, the copyright doesn't even need to be registered with the U.S. Copyright Office to sue on this CMI ground, which is the opposite of traditional copyright infringement lawsuits.

Alan Ross failed to prove violation of this law according to the court.  As to distribution of false CMI, which was alleged to be done by Machinio at a blanket copyright notice found in the terms of use of Machinio's website, the court ruled that this separate terms website is not conveyed with the works on other websites and thus cannot be false CMI connected to the works.  As to the claim that Machinio removed the CMI in the form of copyright notice found at the bottom of Alan Ross's webpages, the court ruled this notice covered Alan Ross's website itself and not the particular sales listings, so just copying the facts in the form of sales listings did not allow for a claim of removal of CMI from a copyrighted work.

The second claim was for false designation of origin under the Lanham Act, which is the trademark law of the U.S..  False designation of origin exists when a manufacturer or seller lies about the country or origin or maker of its products.  This is kind of analogous to CMI removal claims, just in the branding or source identifier context.

Unfortunately for Alan Ross, there was a prior Supreme Court case called Dastar which ruled that these claims attach only to the producer of tangible goods offered for sale, not to authors of any idea or concept embodied in those goods.  In this case, the copied elements of sales listings were deemed to be ideas or communications embodied in the sales listings, as the actual website listings of Machinio were made by the source of those products.  In other words, Machinio produced website listings using someone else's content, and these website listings did not falsely designate Alan Ross as the source of the website listings, so no breaking of the laws just like the prior Dastar decision.  This is a nuanced application of that prior case, but it makes sense.

The Bottom Line is, Alan Ross Machinery tried to come up with some creative ways under the U.S. laws to enforce their rights and stop the practice of web scraping done by Machinio on the sales listings from the Alan Ross website, but these lesser-known enforcement methods did not work in this case.  However, the lesson to be learned is that there's usually some way to try and stop copying of content even if the traditional methods of IP enforcement do not work, and good legal counsel can open doors not often known to exist in these fields.  Especially in cutting edge fields like internet commerce with relatively newer practices like web scraping.

----------------------------------
Do you have a question? Send it in!

Thanks for reading. Please provide feedback and legal-themed questions as segment suggestions to me on Twitter @BuckeyeFitzy


Monday, December 3, 2018

Legal Geek No. 154: Fingerprint Fakes and 2018 Privacy Holiday Gift Guide

Hi, and welcome back to Legal Geek. This week, we cover a couple of interesting stories from the field of privacy law.  First, a story about the development of master fake fingerprints, and second, a guide to the holiday gift season, from a tech nerd and privacy/information security context.


Researchers at New York University and Michigan State University have been working on fingerprints for unlocking biometric sensors such as the TouchID sensor on newer iPhones.  These so-called master fingerprints are not based on the conventional method of copying a genuine user's actual fingerprint, but instead, these are based on analysis with artificial intelligence of common fingerprint patterns.  The AI uses a discriminator to identify common features and combine them into a realistic fingerprint.

To this end, the fake master fingerprints have been tested on a number of devices like iPhones, and these fingerprints developed by the AI unlocked about a quarter of the devices.  That's a far cry from the odds of a fingerprint match publicized by Apple, which is 1 in 50,000.  

Why is this so different in reality?  The sensors used on current phones and laptops typically are small, which means only a portion of a full fingerprint is ever recorded.  That creates fewer data points to make a successful match, and a much higher likelihood of fake matches of the fewer data points.  It's eye-opening research for those who rely on biometric identifiers as the security of the future, as once again, smart computers and college researchers prove how easy such security measures can still be to overcome.  Kudos to NYU and Sparty for some very interesting research.

Turning to our holiday-themed story, Mozilla has investigated 70 top holiday gift items for 2018 to see how they stack up on minimum security standards.  Products are rated on a scale of not very creepy to super creepy, with feedback on everything from readability of the privacy policy associated with the product to the use of cameras, microphones, and location tracking.  For those who don't think about the ever-increasing amount of smart devices and the data they collect, this is a fun educational experience into all of these aspects consumers should care about.

In an era where even grandparents are learning about data privacy from Facebook and similar social networks, it would not be surprising to see more consumers trend towards products that treat data security better.  So if you're curious how all the roombas, security cameras, and BB-8 toys around you are planning to take over the world in the future robot revolution, check out this project by searching Mozilla Privacy Not Included on any search browser.

The Bottom Line is, nothing says holiday season like consumer privacy and data security.  While manufacturers like Apple will try and sell products based on things like biometric identifier scanners, nonprofits like Mozilla and researchers will continue to do the heavy lifting to let consumers know which companies are developing more secure products.  Nobody wants a data breach to ruin this season, after all.  Here's to being smart consumers in holiday season 2018 and beyond.

----------------------------------
Do you have a question? Send it in!

Thanks for reading. Please provide feedback and legal-themed questions as segment suggestions to me on Twitter @BuckeyeFitzy

Sunday, November 25, 2018

Legal Geek No. 153: Which University Owns Block O?

Hi, and welcome back to Legal Geek. This week, to celebrate the end of the college football regular season and the national championship chase, we review an ongoing trademark opposition battle between two universities who have been and continue to be rivals on the football field when jockeying for playoff berths.  The question at hand: who is entitled to own a Block O in trademark or branding?



My alma mater the Ohio State University is one of the most active trademark registrants and brand protectors in the field, as millions of dollars of revenue are enhanced or protected by the brands of the university.  You won't be surprised to learn this is one of the parties in the dispute we cover today, and this is not the first trademark battle in recent times for this OSU.  

For example, last year Ohio State tussled with Oklahoma State University over the rights to "OSU" related marks on apparel and other goods.  However, that 2017 battle ended quickly as the universities replaced a prior deal over geographic area exclusivity with one based on color schemes, which are different for the two universities.  With universities becoming more national and international brands, this type of change in peaceful co-existence agreements is becoming pretty typical.  So don't expect to buy any Cowboys gear for Oklahoma State in scarlet and gray, or any Buckeyes gear for Ohio State in orange and black.

Now turning back to this year, the University of Oklahoma filed a federal trademark application on a logo of a band drum major with a block O on the chest of the uniform.  Ohio State has opposed this trademark after allowance in an attempt to stop formal registration of the logo by Oklahoma.  As we've covered on previous segments, trademark opposition processes allow for third parties who believe they have superior or older rights in a mark to argue for an allowed trademark application to be withdrawn before it registers as a finalized trademark, and this is the final step in the trademark registration process in the U.S..

Many college sports programs use block-style fonts, but Ohio State argues that Oklahoma more typically identifies with "OU" block letters and marks than just a block O.  Furthermore, Ohio State argues that Oklahoma band drum majors rarely wear a block O on their chest, and the block O brands have been developed and used since 1898 by Ohio State to identify that university.  In other words, a case for consumer confusion is being made over the logo being registered, but this is also Ohio State trying to stop any potential competition in the Block O brand space.

Oklahoma has had drum majors wear such a uniform on at least one occasion, so that assertion by Ohio State may not be deemed persuasive by the Trademark Appeal Board.  While the OSU marching band may be a famous part of their university, they have long worn military style uniforms that do not include a big Block O, so the claims about owning Block O in this specific logo's context may also fall flat with the Appeal Board.  The key in trademarks is consumer confusion, and it feels like it will be an uphill battle for Ohio State to prove confusion with this Oklahoma registration.

The Bottom Line is, universities are branding experts as this is one of the primary ongoing revenue streams for them.  While most may pay more attention to the potential cash being made for college football playoff appearances Oklahoma and Ohio State compete for, these battles in branding may actually have more long term economic effect.  In this case, expect Boomer Sooner to roll on to the next round.

----------------------------------
Do you have a question? Send it in!

Thanks for reading. Please provide feedback and legal-themed questions as segment suggestions to me on Twitter @BuckeyeFitzy


Monday, November 12, 2018

Legal Geek No. 152: Pokemon Go to Patent Infringement?

Hi, and welcome back to Legal Geek. This week, we review an ongoing lawsuit between Niantic, the maker of Pokémon Go, and a patent owner who owns a geotagging patent, and what the potential damages could be for this popular phone game.

News broke a few weeks ago of Niantic exceeding $2 billion dollars in revenue from their hit software app Pokémon Go.  Later this week, the Nintendo Switch will have the first classic-style Pokémon game come out for the system called Pokémon Let's Go Eevee and Pokémon Let's Go Pikachu, and these games are also configured to integrate with the phone app phenomenon.  That could make Pokémon Go even more popular again.  But all this financial success draws the risk of lawsuits, which is exactly what is happening in this Delaware case we cover today.

Blackbird Tech LLC is the owner of U.S. Patent No. 9,802,127 on a "Video game including user determined location information."  The general gist of the claims in this Patent are to cover a computer game or method where GPS signals are used to read a first physical location of a user and then displaying images of the first physical location on a user's device along with virtual objects that are not physically present at the first physical location on the user's device.  In other words, the game displays a map or current image of the user's surroundings and adds virtual elements to it.  This set of claims was clearly tailored to target covering augmented reality games.

Blackbird's patent has an original filing date stemming back to 2011, and it issued in October last year.  So in December, Blackbird sued Niantic and claimed Pokémon Go infringes the claims of this patent.  Niantic decided to file a motion to dismiss claiming that the Patent was invalid under recent software patent rules stemming from a Supreme Court decision entitled Alice v CLS Bank.

The Alice decision makes software patents and business method patents invalid if they merely recite abstract ideas performed on generic computer equipment.  This decision has led to a slew of patents being rejected or invalidated, as the abstract idea rules tend to be broadly applied.  But here, the judge in a Delaware federal court ruled last week that Niantic oversimplified the claims of Blackbird's patent in arguing that they were covering just an abstract idea.  The court noted that the system and method in the claims actually takes images of actual locations before integrating those images into the virtual video game environment, which is allegedly more than just an abstract idea.  Seems like a close call to this patent attorney, but it was good enough to overcome a motion to dismiss.

The result is that the case will continue through the discovery process, unless the parties settle with one another.  Niantic's attempt to swat this case away quickly has failed, and a long expensive fight in court will thus be ahead.  Niantic may still prevail on a non-infringement or invalidity argument in the full trial, but it will take months of litigation work to determine those grounds.

If Niantic loses this case, remedies such as money damages or an injunction to shut down the game may occur.  It is far more likely that money damages would be awarded, but that could still seriously impact the future development of the popular phone app.  The stakes are huge, and that explains why both parties are willing to fight this out so far in court.

The Bottom Line is, in many fields like software, there are usually ongoing patent application families with relatively broad disclosures which can later become patents when they happen to cover later developments that become big money makers, like augmented reality games.  It can be really hard to avoid these risks when you're a big success like Niantic, and it seems to be just an added cost of doing business under the current U.S. IP regime.  We will keep our eyes on this case and provide updates when available, but in the meantime, enjoy catching those digital pocket monsters.

Also, RIP to Stan Lee, who was blessed to live long enough to see his stories become a major hit film franchise and inspiring to so many people in our community and beyond.  Excelsior!

----------------------------------
Do you have a question? Send it in!

Thanks for reading. Please provide feedback and legal-themed questions as segment suggestions to me on Twitter @BuckeyeFitzy